A recent case in Cincinnati has brought up an interesting question. The case itself, however, is quite tragic. An 8-year-old boy took his own life after enduring chronic bullying at Carson Elementary School. Students found the boy lying on the bathroom floor. Security cameras show them poking and prodding him to get him to move. A police officer who reviewed the tape said that one student was acting in a menacing manner toward another. This same boy is seen on tape pulling the 8-year-old to the ground by his hand. School officials told the parents that their son had fainted. Now, their parents have filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the school district. Can they win?
There are several elements to this case that will need to be sorted out by the courts. Here we will take a look at some of the key hurdles facing the parents as they fight to hold the school district accountable.
Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 2305.10(A) directly addresses how personal injury and wrongful death lawsuits are handled by the courts. An individual has two years to file a claim against the government and noneconomic damages (which are commonly quite high in a wrongful death action) are capped at $250,000.
In addition, there are limitations on what kinds of claims can be brought against the government. This looks to figure into the aforementioned case as the school district claims that they have no responsibility to prevent violence between students.
The school district claims that they have no legal responsibility to prevent violence between students. If violence occurs, then the school district cannot be held liable.
Essentially, the parents are arguing that this is a premises liability lawsuit on a theory of negligent security. They will claim that the school district fostered an environment that was hostile to their child and the result of that was the taking of his own life.
Thus far, a circuit court judge has refused to dismiss the parents’ lawsuit, prompting an appeal. If the case is allowed to move forward, the question of what the school administrators and teachers knew prior to the boy’s suicide will be quite important.
If a patron walks into a bar and is assaulted by another patron, the bar can be held liable under negligent security statutes. The bar has a duty of care to ensure that all of their patrons are safe and if they had reason to believe that they might not be safe (ie: something happened in the neighborhood or at the bar beforehand), then the bar would be responsible. However, school districts are held to a lower standard than bars.
If you have been injured, call the Ohio personal injury attorneys at Lafferty, Gallagher, & Scott for a free case evaluation. We can help.
I was hurt in a very bad car accident. I worked with Attorney Scott and he was so patient with me. He gave me options and communicated very well with me. Nicole in the office, she was beyond amazing! She…
Our family worked with Joe Hartle to finalize the adoption of our daughter last fall. So while we were not the typical client of this firm, we still had a great experience. Joe is the best, was so friendly, easy…
Attorney Scott helped me with my car accident case. I highly recommend Attorney Scott. He was very good about explaining things to me, and I am very happy with the results. Thank you!
Attorney Lafferty handled my car accident vs. pedestrian case. Very happy with the service and representation he provided. Great result!
Attorney Scott was wonderful in his representation of me for my car accident.
I was represented by Joe Hartle, who did a great job with my auto accident claim. Very happy with the end result.
Highly recommended. The attorneys are very knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly. They did an outstanding job representing us after a terrible car accident caused us serious injuries.
Joe Hartle represented us in a wrongful death case involving a semi-truck. He did an outstanding job during a very trying time in our life. Thank you!
Excellent service all the way around. Happy to recommend Lafferty Gallagher & Scott
Very professional and informative. Thank you to Attorney Jon Lafferty.